Clean vs VS Factory Rolex Submariner Replica: The Ultimate Comparison Guide (2025)

When it comes to replica Rolex watches, the Submariner is undoubtedly the most iconic and sought-after model. Among the many factories that produce high-end replicas, Clean Factory and VS Factory stand out as industry leaders in 2025. But how do their versions of the Rolex Submariner truly compare? In this expert-level guide, we will dissect every key element of their Submariner offerings—from movement and case finishing to bezel quality and lume performance—to determine which factory reigns supreme for discerning replica collectors.

1. Brand Background: Clean Factory vs VS Factory

Clean Factory emerged after the fall of Noob, inheriting much of its supplier network and production experience. Known for its precision bezel work and exceptional dial printing, Clean quickly earned a reputation as the benchmark for replica Rolex models, particularly the Submariner 116610LN and 126610LN.

VS Factory, on the other hand, has a longer history in the replica market. Originating with high-quality Panerai and Omega models, VS has developed its own super clone movement technology and is now one of the few competitors capable of producing Rolex replicas with proprietary Dandong-based calibers.

2. Movement Comparison

Clean Submariner: The Clean Submariner uses the Dandong 3135 movement—an extremely stable and well-finished clone of Rolex’s Calibre 3135. It offers a smooth hand-wind, accurate beat rate, and reliable timekeeping. However, it is not fully independently developed by Clean but sourced from top-tier movement makers.

VS Submariner: VS takes the lead here by integrating their in-house modified Dandong 3135 and 3235 movements in both the 40mm and 41mm models. Their version of the 3235 even includes an independently adjustable hour hand, a hallmark of Rolex’s true movement. These in-house developments provide better longevity and structural integrity.

Winner: VS Factory, due to superior movement customization and integration.

3. Case and Finishing

Both Clean and VS factories use 904L stainless steel, which offers higher corrosion resistance and sheen compared to the 316L steel used by older factories.

• Clean: Known for its sharper lugs, polished sides, and nearly flawless brushing patterns. The transition between polished and brushed areas is exacting.
• VS: Slightly rounder lug shape and marginally softer brushing. The case is still high-quality but lacks the razor-sharp transitions of Clean’s version.

Winner: Clean Factory, for superior precision in case finishing.

4. Bezel Quality and Action

• Clean: Features the best ceramic bezel insert in the replica market. Platinum-filled markers are evenly applied, and the click action is clean, solid, and well-aligned with zero back play.
• VS: Bezel insert is slightly darker. Click action is smooth but not as crisp. In some batches, slight alignment issues have been reported.

Winner: Clean Factory, with class-leading bezel quality and feel.

5. Dial, Hands, and Print Quality

Clean: Dials are made with meticulous care. The font weight, spacing, and alignment are nearly identical to genuine Rolex dials. Hands are finished with mirror polish and accurate lume application.

VS: VS has improved over the years, especially on the 41mm Submariner. However, in side-by-side comparisons, the white print sometimes appears slightly off-white or overly thick.

Winner: Clean Factory, especially in dial printing accuracy and hand quality.

6. Crystal and Cyclops Lens

Both factories use high-quality sapphire crystals with correct AR coating under the cyclops. However:

• Clean: Cyclops magnification and anti-reflective coating are near-perfect. Minimal glare and excellent date window clarity.
• VS: Also excellent, but with slightly more blue tint under some lighting conditions.

Winner: Clean Factory, by a slight margin.

7. Lume Performance

Clean: Lume is strong and long-lasting. Consistent across markers and hands.

• VS: Also very good, but slightly dimmer on the 6 and 9 o’clock markers in some batches.

Winner: Clean Factory

8. Bracelet and Clasp

Both factories offer Oyster bracelets with glidelock extensions. However, there are key differences:

• Clean: Smooth bracelet finish, minimal gap between end links and case. Glidelock is buttery and secure.
• VS: Bracelet links are slightly looser in some batches. Glidelock works well but lacks the refined feel of Clean’s clasp mechanism.

Winner: Clean Factory

9. Price and Value Proposition

As of 2025:

• Clean Submariner typically sells for $450–$520
• VS Submariner is slightly higher, around $480–$550

Value Analysis: VS offers a better movement, but Clean offers a more visually accurate and refined overall package. For most replica buyers seeking a 1:1 aesthetic, Clean offers the best value. For movement enthusiasts and Rolex nerds, VS is worth the premium.

10. Final Verdict: Which Submariner Replica Should You Buy in 2025?

If you’re looking for the most visually accurate, reliable, and balanced Rolex Submariner replica, the Clean Factory Submariner is currently the king. From bezel to bracelet, it’s a masterclass in modern replica craftsmanship.

However, if you value in-house movement innovation and long-term reliability more than visual perfection, then the VS Submariner is an excellent and future-proof choice—especially in the 41mm Datejust or 40mm Sub series using their clone 3235 movement.

Our Recommendation: Buy the Clean 116610LN for all-around authenticity. Choose VS 41mm for advanced movement lovers.